Why BMI Is Not Enough to Measure Obesity
Share
For many years, doctors have used Body Mass Index (BMI) to define if someone is overweight or obese. It is calculated using your height and weight. While it is easy and cheap, BMI has several problems. It does not tell us how much fat or muscle someone has. It also does not show where the fat is in the body, which matters for health risks.
For example, a bodybuilder with lots of muscle may have a high BMI but very little fat. On the other hand, someone with normal BMI could have a lot of hidden fat inside their belly, which increases the risk of heart disease and diabetes.
The Problem with Relying on BMI Alone
BMI is a general tool used for large populations, but it does not work well for individuals. It doesn’t consider age, sex, or ethnicity. In some studies, people with normal BMI had too much body fat, while others with high BMI had healthy fat levels. This mismatch means many people are not getting the right treatment because their BMI does not reflect their real health risk.
There’s also something called TOFI – thin on the outside, fat on the inside. These people have normal weight but high levels of belly fat, which is linked to serious health issues like heart disease. On the flip side, some people with high BMI have good blood sugar, normal cholesterol, and healthy blood pressure. This is called metabolically healthy obesity (MHO). But even they are still at higher risk than lean people.
Better Ways to Measure Obesity
To understand real body fat and health risk, doctors are now using tools that measure body composition. These tools can show fat percentage, fat distribution, and muscle mass. Some of the common methods include:
- Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA): Simple, affordable, and used in many gyms or clinics. But its accuracy can vary based on hydration, medications, and other factors.
- Dual-energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA): More accurate than BIA and provides a detailed picture of fat and muscle. It is safe and becoming more available.
- CT and MRI scans: These are the most accurate methods to measure fat types and locations, especially belly and heart fat. But they are expensive and not always available.
These methods help doctors understand who really needs treatment and how well a treatment is working.
Why Muscle Mass Also Matters
Fat is not the only thing to watch. Losing muscle while treating obesity can be a problem. Some weight loss medicines might reduce both fat and muscle. This can lead to weakness and poor health, especially in older adults. That’s why it’s important to track not just fat but also muscle quality and quantity.
Tools like DEXA, MRI, or even muscle ultrasound can help track changes in muscle during treatment. Maintaining muscle while reducing fat should be the goal of any healthy weight loss plan.
A New Way to Set Obesity Goals
Currently, doctors often use BMI to decide who can get obesity treatments. But BMI doesn’t tell us when to stop treatment or if it’s working well. A better idea is to use body fat percentage. For example, having more than 35% body fat in men and 42% in women may be considered obesity. These numbers give a more accurate and personal goal for treatment.
With clear targets based on body fat, doctors can make better decisions and even stop treatment when it’s no longer needed.
What the Future Looks Like
In the future, measuring obesity will go beyond BMI. Technology and artificial intelligence (AI) are being used to analyze body scans and give detailed reports. This will help doctors personalize treatment for each person based on their body composition, not just weight.
It’s time to move towards more accurate and fair ways of measuring obesity. Doing so can help more people get the care they need and avoid treating those who don’t.