What Muscle Strength Can Tell Us About Bone Health
Share
As we get older, our bones and muscles naturally weaken. For women after menopause, this can lead to a higher risk of fragile bones and unexpected fractures. These are called “fragility fractures” and can happen from simple actions like a small fall or even turning awkwardly. But what if we could use muscle strength as a warning sign before these breaks happen?
A new 10-year study looked at just that and gives us helpful clues.
What Was the Study About?
Researchers followed nearly 1,500 postmenopausal women in Switzerland for over a decade. They wanted to know if measuring muscle strength and muscle mass could help predict who might suffer a bone fracture.
Two key indicators were used:
- Handgrip strength (HGS): how hard someone can squeeze using a special device
- Lean muscle mass: how much muscle (not fat) someone has, especially in the arms and legs
They checked these measurements every few years and compared them with how many women had fractures, fell, or passed away.
What Did the Researchers Find?
Over 10 years, 260 women had a fracture, including spine, hip, arm, or wrist fractures. The biggest takeaway was this:
- Women with weaker grip strength were more likely to suffer a fracture
- Women with lower muscle mass (especially when not adjusted for their body weight or fat) had shorter times before a fracture occurred
Interestingly, women with more muscle mass actually had a higher risk of fracture unless that number was adjusted to account for their body weight or fat. This means that raw muscle mass alone is not a clear indicator unless seen in relation to the person’s size.
Why Body Weight and Fat Matter
It turns out that body weight and fat play a big role in how muscle measurements affect bone health. When the researchers adjusted muscle mass in relation to body mass index (BMI), they got more accurate predictions.
For example:
- A woman with low muscle mass but also low weight may be at risk
- A woman with more muscle mass but also higher fat might not be protected unless the muscle is strong and active
So it’s not just about having more muscle, but how that muscle fits with the rest of your body.
What About Falls and Death?
Even though grip strength helped predict fractures, it didn’t clearly show who was likely to fall or pass away. This might be because the women in the study were relatively healthy at the start. Other studies do suggest that lower muscle strength can lead to more falls and even higher mortality, but this group was too healthy to show those effects.
What Can We Learn From This?
If you’re a postmenopausal woman—or care for someone who is—this study highlights a few practical lessons:
- Muscle strength matters: A simple handgrip strength test can give important clues about bone health.
- Don’t ignore body composition: Just having more muscle doesn’t always mean you’re safe. Muscle has to be strong and balanced with your body weight and fat.
- Prevention is better than cure: By staying physically active, eating enough protein, and doing strength-based exercises, you can improve your muscle strength and possibly reduce your risk of fractures.
Should You Ask Your Doctor About Muscle Testing?
It could be worth it, especially if you’re at risk for osteoporosis. Handgrip strength is easy to measure, and many clinics can offer body composition scans. These numbers could help build a clearer picture of your future fracture risk.
However, as the study points out, these muscle tests don’t replace other tools like bone scans or the FRAX calculator. But they can add more detail and help doctors make better decisions.
Final Thoughts
This research shows that muscle health and bone health are deeply connected. Paying attention to strength and body composition might help predict serious problems before they happen. For women in midlife and beyond, maintaining strong muscles isn't just about mobility—it might be a shield against painful and life-changing fractures.