What Happens When an Athlete Fails a Heart Screening?
Share
Before athletes compete at a high level, they often go through heart screenings to check for any hidden heart conditions. These tests are meant to prevent rare but serious events like sudden cardiac arrest during intense exercise. But what happens if something unusual shows up in the screening?
This article breaks down what an abnormal result means and what an athlete should do next.
Why Cardiac Screening Is Important
Many heart conditions that could cause problems during sports don’t show symptoms in daily life. That’s why screenings like ECGs (electrocardiograms) or echocardiograms are used to detect early warning signs. These tests look for changes in the heart's rhythm, structure, or function that could increase the risk of heart issues during exercise.
If something suspicious is found, further tests are needed to confirm whether there’s a real problem.
Can Athletes Keep Training While Waiting?
This is one of the biggest questions athletes and their families ask. The answer depends on what kind of abnormality was found.
High-risk signs such as chest pain during exercise, fainting without warning, or dangerous patterns on an ECG usually mean the athlete should pause training until more tests are done.
Low-risk or borderline findings, like small changes in the heart's electrical activity or vague symptoms, may allow athletes to continue training—especially if they’re being monitored closely and tests are scheduled quickly.
In all cases, it’s important to act fast and avoid long delays between the first screening and the follow-up evaluation.
Types of Abnormalities and Their Meaning
Some signs that may suggest a heart problem include:
- A very long QT interval on an ECG
- Irregular heartbeats (arrhythmias)
- Signs of thickened heart walls or weakened pumping function
- Unusual origin of coronary arteries
These findings don’t always mean something is seriously wrong, but they need to be taken seriously. On the other hand, some changes in an athlete’s heart are just normal results of regular training and are not dangerous.
What Should Be Done Next?
When an abnormal result is found, the medical team should:
- Clearly explain the findings to the athlete and their family
- Schedule additional tests like an echocardiogram or MRI
- Decide who will perform and interpret those tests
- Create a plan that avoids unnecessary delays
If the tests confirm a low-risk condition, the athlete may return to full training. If a more serious issue is confirmed, further decisions are made on a case-by-case basis with input from a sports cardiologist.
Balancing Safety and Performance
In some cases, athletes may be allowed to do low to moderate exercise under supervision, while waiting for final results. This helps them maintain fitness and mental well-being.
But in all cases, safety comes first. Any return to full competition should happen only when it’s safe to do so. Having emergency plans in place, like access to a defibrillator and trained medical staff, is essential.
The Role of Shared Decision-Making
Doctors, athletes, and families need to make decisions together. This shared decision-making approach helps everyone understand the risks and options. Doctors must explain what is known, what is still uncertain, and what the potential consequences are.
Written records of these discussions are important to protect everyone legally and medically.
What the Research Says
New research shows that even athletes with certain heart conditions like hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) may be able to exercise safely with proper monitoring. However, these athletes were usually under expert care and had personalized plans.
So while the risks are real, they are not the same for everyone. Decisions should be based on individual risk, not just a one-size-fits-all rule.
Conclusion
An abnormal heart screening result in an athlete is not the end of their career. It’s the start of a careful process to make sure they stay safe while continuing their passion for sport.
If you're an athlete or a parent of one, remember:
- Take screenings seriously
- Don’t panic if something is abnormal
- Work closely with experts
- Ask questions and stay informed
With the right steps, most athletes can return to training and competition with confidence and safety.