Smith Machine Squat vs Leg Press
Share
Introduction
When it comes to leg workouts, two popular exercises stand out—the Smith machine back squat and the horizontal leg press. Many gym-goers wonder if one is better than the other. A recent study published in the European Journal of Applied Physiology dives deep into how these two exercises affect muscle fatigue, hormone levels, and recovery in healthy men. The results can help you train smarter, not just harder.
The Study in Simple Terms
Researchers had 12 active men perform high-volume workouts with both the Smith machine squat (SQ) and the horizontal leg press (LP). Each exercise involved five sets of ten reps using heavy loads. Scientists measured changes in muscle strength, jump height, and hormone levels before and after the workouts—and again 30 minutes, 24 hours, and 48 hours later.
Key Findings
- More Total Work with Squats: Participants did significantly more physical work during squats than during leg presses. This is because squats use more of your body weight and involve greater movement.
- Higher Hormonal Response with Squats: Squats triggered higher increases in cortisol (a stress hormone) and growth hormone right after the workout, likely due to greater workload and more muscles involved.
- Muscle Fatigue Happens with Both: Despite differences in total work, both exercises led to similar short-term fatigue in the legs. This was measured by reduced force, jump height, and muscle responsiveness.
- Recovery Within 24 Hours: Most participants recovered fully within 24 hours, regardless of the exercise. However, muscle damage markers (like creatine kinase) stayed higher longer after squats.
What This Means for Your Workouts
Both exercises are effective, but they serve slightly different purposes:
- Choose Squats for Hormonal and Full-Body Benefit: The Smith machine squat may be better for boosting overall metabolic and hormonal response. It's more demanding and engages stabilizing muscles in the hips, back, and core.
- Choose Leg Press for Targeted Muscle Fatigue: The horizontal leg press isolates the quadriceps more and puts less stress on your back. It's great for hypertrophy (muscle growth) and useful in rehab settings.
Tips for Applying This Knowledge
- Mix Both Into Your Routine: You don’t have to pick one. Start with squats to get the full-body benefit, then add leg presses to further fatigue your legs.
- Rest 24 Hours Between Heavy Sessions: Both exercises cause fatigue, but your body usually recovers within a day. Plan rest or alternate muscle groups accordingly.
- Adjust Load and Volume Based on Goals: Use higher reps and moderate weights for endurance and hypertrophy, or lower reps with heavier weights for strength gains.
- Pay Attention to Your Recovery: If soreness or fatigue lasts longer than 24–48 hours, consider reducing the intensity or volume next time.
Final Takeaway
This study shows that while the Smith machine squat triggers a stronger hormonal and physical response, the leg press is equally effective at tiring your legs. The choice depends on your training goals. Use both smartly and give your body time to recover for the best results.