Does Eating More Protein Harm Your Bones?
Share
For years, people have heard that eating too much protein—especially animal protein—can be bad for your bones. The idea was that protein increases acid in the body, which pulls calcium from your bones and weakens them over time. But is this concern supported by science? Let’s break it down simply.
The Protein-Bone Myth Explained
The belief that high-protein diets damage bones comes from something called the acid-ash hypothesis. This theory suggests that eating a lot of protein, especially from meat and grains, creates an acidic environment in the body. In response, the body may use calcium from bones to neutralize the acid, leading to bone loss.
But this idea has a few flaws:
- It assumes that calcium in urine must come from bone, which isn’t always true.
- It doesn’t consider how the body actually absorbs and uses calcium.
- It ignores the bigger picture of the whole diet—especially the benefits of fruits, vegetables, and exercise.
What the Science Really Says
Research over the past decade has shown that protein does not harm bone health—and may actually help it.
In fact, protein makes up a large part of your bone structure. Around 50% of bone volume and 33% of bone mass is protein. Without enough protein, your body can’t build or maintain strong bones.
Protein also stimulates a hormone called IGF-1 (insulin-like growth factor-1), which plays a key role in bone growth and repair.
High Protein May Help Your Bones
Recent studies and reviews show that higher protein intakes:
- Improve bone mineral density
- Reduce the rate of bone loss
- Lower the risk of fractures (especially in older adults)
One large review even found that people who ate more than the standard recommended amount of protein had stronger bones, as long as they also got enough calcium and vitamin D.
Even in studies where participants consumed over 2.2 g of protein per kg of body weight per day (nearly 3x the basic recommendation), no harm to bone health was found. In fact, some of these individuals even experienced improvements in bone strength and density.
Where Did the Confusion Come From?
The acid-ash theory oversimplified how the body works. Yes, protein can raise calcium levels in urine—but that doesn't mean it's coming from your bones. It could simply be from better absorption of calcium in the intestines.
Also, many people with low bone density tend to eat too little protein, not too much.
Practical Advice for Strong Bones
Here’s how to protect your bones while getting enough protein:
- Eat balanced meals: Pair your protein with plenty of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. This supports a more neutral pH and adds bone-friendly nutrients.
- Get enough calcium and vitamin D: These are essential for bone health—aim for dairy, leafy greens, fortified foods, or supplements if needed.
- Strength train: Lifting weights or doing resistance exercises strengthens both muscles and bones.
- Don’t fear high protein: Aim for 1.2–2.0 g/kg of body weight per day, especially if you’re active or aging.
Final Thoughts
The idea that protein harms bone health is outdated and not supported by science. In reality, getting enough protein—along with proper nutrition and regular exercise—is one of the best things you can do to support strong bones.
So don’t let old myths stop you from fueling your body properly. Eat your protein and protect your bones at the same time.